How to add multiple providers for acceptance tests?

Terraform Providers AWS
1

I’m 95% complete of building a terraform provider for Cloudability.
The repo is here: https://github.com/skyscrapr/terraform-provider-cloudability

I built the provider using some terraform modules to test and my own test methods. The modules are here: https://github.com/skyscrapr/terraform-cloudability-modules

Everything works fine. I’m now trying to implement the documented acceptance testing framework and I need to add the AWS provider to my test provider list. But when i do this i start to get errors that I’m not seeing deploying the modules directly. I’ve pushed my current attempt to a branch here: https://github.com/skyscrapr/terraform-provider-cloudability/blob/broken/cloudability/resource_master_account_test.go

I need to include the AWS provider in the test as these resources require it.
I managed to get this to compile by adding the AWS provider to the test provider list here: https://github.com/skyscrapr/terraform-provider-cloudability/blob/broken/cloudability/provider_test.go#L16

But I’m getting errors executing the module. The errors are around access denied issues trying to access s3 bucket to add a policy or delete the bucket.

Is this the right way to approach this?

thanks for any help

Richard

2

OK I’ve figured out a few issues causing my pain.

The AWS provider resource “aws_cur_report_definition” must run against the us-east-1 region. This can be achieved by using a second aws provider with an alias. However I currently cannot get this to work in an acceptance test.

Futhermore, this resource can fail with a “ValidationException: Failed to verify customer bucket permission…”. This looks like an eventual consistency issue and this error should be retryable. I’ll raise an issue in the AWS provider channel.

3

Just to add more feedback for anyone else that finds this. I found some additional documentation on acceptance testing cross regions here. I think it would make sense to include this in the current acceptance testing documentation because this is important info.

4

Hi skyscrapr, did you ever get this working? What cloudability features / info were you able to integrate?
Looking at a project to figure out how to get rightsizing from cloudability into terraform.

5

All functionality is working except the acceptance tests due to poor multiple provider support.

I’ll take another look at them later today to see if there have been any improvements.

6

Sample modules of all available functionality are in this repo:

Raise an issue if you think there is missing functionality. I’ll take a look at adding it.

7

I just noticed that rightsizing is a new endpoint. I’ll take a look at adding this.

I’ve raised a new issue.